Warning: Spoilers ahead for “Good American Family.”
Hulu’s scripted miniseries “Good American Family,” which recounts the true story of Natalia Grace’s disastrous adoption from multiple perspectives, aired its first season finale on Wednesday.
The dramatic episode, titled “Blood on Her Hands,” follows Natalia (Imogen Faith Reid) as a legal case is mounted against her adoptive parents, Kristine and Michael Barnett, played by Ellen Pompeo and Mark Duplass.
In real life, the Barnetts were arrested and charged with neglect after leaving Natalia in Indiana and moving to Canada. They had adopted her in 2010, believing her to be a 6-year-old Ukrainian orphan, but later claimed Natalia was an adult con artist pretending to be a child. (Natalia has denied all their accusations.)
The Barnetts petitioned a court to re-age Natalia, successfully changing her legal birth year from 2003 to 1989. However, the Barnetts remained her legal guardians as a result of Natalia’s disability.
Natalia, who has a rare form of dwarfism called spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia, was eventually adopted by another set of parents, Cynthia and Antwon Mans, played by Christina Hendricks and Jerod Haynes.
In the TV show, as in real life, the Barnetts don’t go to jail; the case against Michael falls apart when the judge rules against any mention of Natalia’s age in court. The charges against Kristine were later dismissed.
Despite the harsh legal verdict, causing Natalia to fear the world would see her as a “monster,” the finale gestures toward a happier future for Natalia with the Mans family — but that’s not where Natalia’s real story ended.
People interviewed in season three of ID’s docuseries, “The Curious Case of Natalia Grace,” said they witnessed abuse in the Mans household. Natalia also confirmed she’d left the family, and as of January 2025, she said she was living with another family, the DePauls, in New York. Cynthia and Antwon Mans did not respond to BI’s request for comment on the abuse allegations.
Will “Good American Family” return for a second season to keep following the twists and turns of Natalia’s story? Here’s what we know.
‘Good American Family’ creator Katie Robbins said there are no plans for season 2, but ‘never say never’
“Good American Family” was originally created as an eight-episode limited series.
As of writing, Hulu has not announced a renewal. The series creator, Katie Robbins, told TV Insider that the showrunners have not planned for a second season.
“This series ends very specifically where it does,” Robbins said. “At the end of that trial, when there is empirical, scientific fact [available about] Natalia’s age, and having that not change anything in the court of law. Having that be not admissible in the court of law really lands this horrifying idea — in a show that grapples with horror tropes — that is the most kind of horrifying thing at the end of the day, that that doesn’t matter. That doesn’t change anything.”
Although she didn’t definitively rule out another season, Robbins explained the “Good American Family” finale was constructed in a way for the show’s key themes — the deceptive effects of bias, the dangers of performative charity, the fallibility of the justice system — to land “sharply.”
“I think that to do an additional story here, there would need to be a reason, something to say with it,” Robbins said. “And never say never, but that would be the thing: ‘Why tell it?'”
Read the full article here
